Greys GS fly box review

The Greys GS fly box is strong, compact and holds plenty of flies, but the design seems flawed as two of ours have broken in months...

Greys GS fly box review
© Fly and Lure
Greys GS fly box review
Picture copyright © Fly and Lure
Greys GS fly box review
Accessories Greys Fly boxes Estimated reading time 3 - 4 minutes

What's special about the Greys GS fly box?

The Greys GS fly box is small and compact and has lots of room for flies, thanks to a hinged leaf in the middle which holds your patterns on both sides.

It's lightweight and small enough to keep in your pocket, but is also extremely capacious and holds all the flies you'll need for a day of fishing.

How are the flies held in place?

Like the vast majority of fly boxes on the market, these use grey slotted foam with cut-outs to protect dry fly hackles and allow bulkier patterns to slot in without getting too squashed.

With time, this slotted foam stuff gets progressively weaker and can lose its grip on flies, so some manufacturers are now switching towards slotted silicone inserts instead, but the Greys GS fly boxes pre-date that technology. Slotted foam works well enough, though.

How big are they and how many flies do they hold?

There are two models in the Greys GS fly box range - a large one which holds over 450 flies and a medium one which holds 396. The medium one is the one we went for as it's extremely voluminous and packs loads of flies into a neat compact space, easily fitting inside the average jacket pocket.

Model Size Capacity
Medium 13 x 9 x 3.2cm 396 flies
Large 19.5 x 11 x 4.5cm 450+ flies

How much are they?

The medium model sells for around £7.99, while the large one costs £11.99. This is fairly typical for a fly box and quite competitive for fly boxes given the capacity.

Are they strong?

The ABS plastic used seems very robust and has held up well to weekly use. However, the hinge which holds the two sides and the loose leaf together consists of a loose metal pin, seemingly with no retaining clip.

On both of George's Greys GS fly boxes the retaining pin has fallen out and into the undergrowth, never to be seen again, ruining two otherwise perfectly functional fly boxes...

Seeing as you can't really use a fly box when it stops being a box, they've had to be retired from use. I've never had a fly box with such a short lifespan and I probably own about 20!

I've got other fly boxes that have lasted many years, and will undoubtedly last many more, so for two to fall apart in a matter of months isn't very impressive.

Would you buy another?

The fact that two of these have broken as a result of the same issue within months would imply there's a design fault, so I won't be buying another one. Disappointingly, a message to Greys Customer Services to see if they had any replacement pins didn't get any further than the automatic acknowledgement of its receipt...

Which alternative do you recommend?

I have a few Fulling Mill Silicone Fly Boxes and think they're great.

They may not hold as many flies, but they're decent quality and stand-up much better to everyday use than the Greys GS fly box, so I'd be inclined to try one of these instead.

About the author

matt

Comments

  • Iant
    Iant About 2 years ago

    Hi Matt, Assuming that you haven't already lost the "pin", there's an easy fix for this issue (I have this box myself). Simply place a small blob of two-part epoxy adhesive at each end of the hinge. Pin will never come out again! :-) Kind regards, Ian (in Germany)

  • matt
    matt About 2 years ago Author

    Thanks for the great tip, Iant! We'll give that a try on the other boxes before the pins vanish. Cheers, Matt

Fulling Mill fly box range review Fulling Mill's new fly box range includes boxes of all shapes and sizes to suit a range...

Sunray Short Head fly line review The Sunray Short Head fly line is mega thin integrated shooting head style line and is...

Guideline EXP5 fly rod review The Guideline EXP5 fly rod range is an entry-level mid-priced rod with a forgiving...

Iain Barr World Champion's Choice fly selection review If you're a newcomer and struggle to pick the right fly patterns, these carded...

Orvis Clearwater Sink Tip Type III fly line review The Orvis Clearwater Sink Tip Type III fly line lets you fish your flies in the top few...

Sunray Competition Float fly line review The Sunray Competition Float fly line features a new overhang marker which makes...

Fulling Mill grayling jigs review We try out some of Fulling Mill's new grayling jig patterns on the Welsh Dee and find...

Fulling Mill World Class V2 Fluorocarbon review Fulling Mill World Class V2 Fluorocarbon is the new and improved version of this...

Fulling Mill Masterclass Tapered Leaders review Fulling Mill Masterclass Tapered Leaders are fine, strong and reliable and greatly...

Get fly fishing updates

You may unsubscribe at any time. Check our privacy policy for details on how we use and protect your data.